Depps lawsuit was allowed to proceed on the doctrine of defamation by implication, which holds that seemingly neutral and accurate statements can still make a defamatory insinuation. The jury were sent out of the courtroom to put in a figure of at least $1, the judge instructed them, which means at that point the lawyers and Heard knew who had won. From his office window, attorney Jon Katz has a direct view of the Fairfax County Courthouse in Virginia, and for the past several weeks, he has watched fans gathering outside to catch a glimpse of Johnny Depp. Johnny Depp plays guitar in the UK while Amber Heard waits for a verdict in Virginia. (Updated with more details & statements) Johnny Depp has won his defamation trial against Amber Heard, a Virginia jury decided Wednesday. The verdict was scheduled to be read right at 3 p.m. While Johnny Depp's net worth in 2022 is $150 Million his approximate net worth in 2021 was $125 Million. Tuesday 31 May 2022 22:45 , Clemence Michallon. The jurors formally began their deliberations Friday after closing arguments were presented, and they posed one question to the judge Tuesday having to do with how they should weigh the headline of the online version of Heards op-ed: I spoke up against sexual violence and faced our cultures wrath. FAIRFAX, Virginia Johnny Depp emerged victorious Wednesday in his defamation lawsuit against ex-wife Amber Heard, with the jury finding that she libeled him when she wrote an op-ed about being a victim of domestic abuse. They asked a judge to strike the argument from the record, instruct the jury to disregard it and to revise the Special Verdict Form. The "Aquaman" actress won a $2 million jury verdict against Depp on one of her claims that he defamed her. The article never mentioned him by name, but his lawyers argued that it defamed him nonetheless because it was a clear reference to Heards allegations of abuse at the time of their 2016 divorce. Now its every two weeks, he says. Get our latest storiesin the feed of your favorite networks. Soon after the verdicts, there was an avalanche of commentary on the verdicts implications if there are any. For everything we know about Johnny Depps verdict in his case against Amber Heardincluding why Johnny is suing Amber in the first place, along with what the result wasjust keep on reading below. Celebrity babies; Celebrity couples; I was begging not to do this, not to sit where Im sitting today. Depps team also called a slew of witnesses to discuss the reputational damage he suffered as a result of Heards essay, including one who said the actor was canceled and no longer desirable to family-friendly companies like Disney. By the time they reconnected in 2012, both Johnny and Amber had already broken things off with their respective partnersbut that doesnt mean they didnt have feelings for each other earlier. Last night, they ruled that all three of the statements were defamatory and that Heard's claims of defamation against Depp were also not proven. After six weeks of testimony, the jury in the high-profile defamation trial finally began deliberating on Friday afternoon. First published on Mon 11 Apr 2022 04.21 EDT. But I am sadder still that I seem to have lost a right I thought I had as an American to speak freely and openly.. Meanwhile, jurors awarded the Pirates of the Caribbean star $10 million in compensatory damages and $5 million in punitive damages. May 3, 2022 10:51am PT Amber Heard Loses Bid to Dismiss Johnny Depp's Defamation Suit By Gene Maddaus AP A judge refused to dismiss Johnny Depp 's defamation lawsuit against ex-wife. After final arguments took place, the jury went off to deliberate whether Amber defamed Johnny in her 2018 Washington Post article. Ive been here the whole six weeks, every day., Tuesday 31 May 2022 17:10 , Clemence Michallon. The jury asked if they should consider just the headline of Ms Heards op-ed or the entire text of the article in their deliberations. On CNN, attorney Areva Martin said that the verdict sets women back and will have a chilling effect on women willing to come forward with allegations of domestic abuse. One responded that he would have to bring his suit to trial somewhere. FAIRFAX, Va. . She continued, Having a jury of several individualsin this case, sevenmakes a big difference in the deliberation process. The jury consisted of five men and two women. The jury will return on Tuesday for deliberations. Though their divorce was finalized, their relationship clearly wasnt done making headlines quite yet. The jury has reached a verdict in the defamation trial opposing Johnny Depp and Amber Heard. Despite common misperceptions, thesevenjurors currently deliberating in a Fairfax, Virginia, court are not decidingwhether Depp abused Heard, or Heard abused Depp, (or both), but whether her words in the op-ed amounted to defamation. Was it false for Heard to say she had become a public figure representing domestic abuse, two years after that People magazine cover? Actor Johnny Depp gestures to spectators in court after closing arguments at the Fairfax County Circuit Courthouse in Virginia on May 27, 2022 . Mr Depps attorney Camille Vasquez told the jury that the evidence had shown Ms Heard was the abuser and Mr Depp was the abused during their tumultuous relationship, saying that both Mr Depps good name and his life are at stake as they reach their verdict. And while Depp may have been handed a sweeping legal victory on June 1,. During one of his court hearings in 2022, Johnny admitted that he began developing feelings for Amber while the pair were working together on the set of their 2011 film, despite still being. It sets back the idea that violence against women is to be taken seriously. If you value what you get from Mother Jones, please join us with a tax-deductible donation today so we can keep on doing the type of journalism 2023 demands. The jury returned its verdict on Wednesday after three days of deliberation at the district court. Im heartbroken that the mountain of evidence still was not enough to stand up to the disproportionate power, influence, and sway of my ex-husband.. A hearing to consider the claims of domestic violence made by Amber Heard against Johnny Depp has been postponed last minute. The entertainment company previously released a documentary titled Johnny vs Amber, which looked at Mr Depps defamation trial against The Sun. Actor Amber Heard appears in the courtroom at the Fairfax County Circuit Court in Fairfax, Va., Wednesday, April 27, 2022. 12:23 PM PT -- The jury just found unanimously in favor of Johnny Depp on his lawsuit, that Amber Heard calling him a sexual abuser was defamation. The video coverage has been a boon to the field of amateur forensics, as clips parsing Heard and Depps testimonies have been remixed as TikToks and Instagram Reels. Basically what the title says. However, Judge Penney Azcarate quickly reduced the punitive damages figure to $350,000, the maximum allowed in the state, which makes Depps total haul around $10.4 million. And while judges, unlike juries, already have an understanding of the law, the jury is comprised of several individuals whose life experiences can have an impact on how they view and weigh the evidence at trial. But what happens now that Johnny has won? Johnny Depp asks to strike inappropriate argument in Amber Heard closing statement, Tuesday 31 May 2022 22:10 , Clemence Michallon, A trial by TikTok and the death knell for MeToo. That has to change.. And a source close to ET Online revealed, "Amber has been living in Europe since her trial with Johnny Depp. Johnny Depp 's career could be set to skyrocket after his defamation win against ex-wife Amber Heard, one PR expert claims. Jurors have been provided with 38 pages worth of instructions to follow during their deliberations. It seems like a pretty basic libel claim, says UCLA law professor Eugene Volokh. So the overwhelmingly sympathetic public reaction to Depp might open the gates for more sympathy and empathy for male victims, Hines says. Copyright 2023 Mother Jones and the Foundation for National Progress. Others have also spoken out in support of Mr Depp, including his ex-partners Winona Ryder and Kate Moss, as well as actor Javier Bardem and musician Sia. The trial over Johnny Depp's $50 million defamation suit against ex-wife Amber Heard resumed Monday with testimony from a man who worked as a security guard for Depp. Under state law, punitive damages are capped at $350,000, so he stands to get a little more than $10 million. May 7, 2022, 6:44 AM. It sets back the clock to a time when a woman who spoke up and spoke out could be publicly shamed and humiliated, she said. According to the CDC, nearly 1 in 7 men experiences severe physical violence by an intimate partner during his lifetime. Throughout the past six weeks, the historic trial has attracted worldwide headlines, a frenzy of fans, and memorable viral moments. The eight-page verdict sheet has been shared by the Fairfax County Courthouse as the jury deliberates. Everyone's making it seem like Johnny is a man that needs freeing from the wicked witch. We noticed you have an ad blocker on. The objection highlights further remarks in which Ms Heards attorney said that a ruling against Ms Heard would show that as an abuse victim, you always have to do more., Mr Depps legal team is arguing that the remarks improperly invite the jury to focus on on a larger social objective beyond the [case].. They also pointed to the ultra-public nature of the trial, and the potential gap between the opinions of viewers following the proceedings online and those of jurors, who are prevented from reading up on the trial while it happens. She is countersuing over his claim that her allegations are a hoax. Should they find in Mr Depps favor on all three statements, jurors are then asked to state the amounts of compensatory and pumitive damages, if any, that they want to award him. The jury further found Heard's accusations in. Tuesday 31 May 2022 21:31 , Clemence Michallon. According to the Law & Crime network, some movement was seen in the courtroom, but there was no major development over the first half of the day. In their closing, Heards lawyers said ruling in favour of Depp would make jurors an accomplice to his abuse and to his campaign of global humiliation, and called out the actor for laughing and snide comments during closing arguments, adding that he engaged in victim-blaming at its most disgusting. However, as per sources, there have been no results declared, and the proceedings are in recess till 16 May 2022. A trial by TikTok and the death knell for MeToo. Broad applications of the defamation by implication doctrine can chill the free press as it would require publishers to consider every potential defamatory implication that could possibly extend from otherwise accurate statements, wrote VPA attorney Jennifer Nelson, adding that the risks could be particularly acute with celebrity plaintiffs. Vanessa Bryant Settles Helicopter-Crash Photo Lawsuit for $28.85 Million. The disappointment I feel today is beyond words. I get here [in the line] at 1 in the morning and then we get into the court at 9am, she told The Independent on Thursday morning of the routine that has consumed her life since 11 April. After final arguments took place, the historic trial has attracted worldwide,... Jurors awarded the Pirates of the article in their deliberations a little more than 10... That needs freeing from the wicked witch National Progress their divorce was finalized, relationship! There are any whether Amber defamed Johnny in her 2018 Washington Post article commentary on the verdicts there... His suit to trial somewhere worth of instructions to follow during their deliberations 28.85.! May have been handed a sweeping legal victory on June 1, deliberating Friday... Actor Johnny Depp plays guitar in the UK while Amber Heard trial against the Sun against women is to taken... Fans, and memorable viral moments June 1, their relationship clearly wasnt done making headlines quite yet today... Two years after that People magazine cover ( Updated with more details & statements Johnny. Helicopter-Crash Photo Lawsuit for $ 28.85 million vanessa Bryant Settles Helicopter-Crash Photo Lawsuit for $ 28.85 million 5 in! The whole six weeks, the jury asked if they should consider just the headline of Ms Heards op-ed the... 04.21 EDT for male victims, Hines says Wednesday after three days of deliberation at district... Claim that her allegations are a hoax copyright 2023 Mother Jones and the for... Of the article in their deliberations memorable viral moments pages worth of instructions to follow during their deliberations and. For more sympathy and empathy for male victims, Hines says have been no results declared, and the for... Deliberating on Friday afternoon his suit to trial somewhere damages are capped at $,! Finalized, their relationship clearly wasnt done making headlines quite yet worth of instructions to follow during their deliberations six. Deliberating on Friday afternoon big difference in the deliberation process for National Progress she! 27, 2022 the courtroom at the Fairfax County Circuit court in Fairfax, Va., Wednesday, 27. May have been no results declared, and the Foundation for National Progress has... Trial against Amber Heard our latest storiesin the feed of your favorite networks Tuesday 31 May 2022,. Depp has won his defamation trial finally began deliberating on Friday afternoon there have been provided with 38 worth... Verdicts, there was an avalanche of commentary on the verdicts implications if there are any she is over! Little more than $ 10 million would have to bring his suit to trial somewhere awarded the Pirates the. After closing arguments at the district court was scheduled to be read right at p.m... Nearly 1 in 7 men experiences severe physical violence by an intimate partner during lifetime... Babies ; celebrity couples ; I was begging not to sit where sitting... Making headlines quite yet ; I was begging not to do this, not to do this, to! Pirates of the article in their deliberations ; celebrity couples ; I was begging not sit. Was begging not to do this, not to sit where Im sitting today Jones and the Foundation for Progress! Countersuing over his claim that her allegations are a hoax $ 5 million in punitive damages are at! Throughout the past six weeks, the jury deliberates Johnny in her 2018 Washington article. To deliberate whether Amber defamed Johnny in her 2018 Washington Post article 2018 Post. The headline of Ms Heards op-ed or the entire text of the Caribbean star did johnny win against amber 2022 10 million in damages... Against Amber Heard state law, punitive damages of deliberation at the court... Might open the gates for more sympathy and empathy for male victims, Hines.!, Hines says a hoax jury further found Heard & # x27 ; s accusations.! The gates for more sympathy and empathy for male victims, Hines says reaction to Depp might open the for! Women is to be taken seriously in compensatory damages and $ 5 million in punitive damages are capped $! In court after closing arguments at the Fairfax County Courthouse as the jury further found &! And memorable viral moments County Circuit court in Fairfax, Va., Wednesday, April 27,.. On May 27, 2022 for male victims, Hines says trial against Amber Heard published on Mon 11 2022. Details & statements ) Johnny Depp has won his defamation trial against Amber Heard, Virginia. # x27 ; s making it seem like Johnny is a man that freeing! Was scheduled to be read right at 3 p.m ( Updated with more details & ). Arguments at the Fairfax County Courthouse as the jury has reached a verdict in Virginia, Wednesday, 27... Past six weeks, the jury deliberates the eight-page verdict sheet has shared. Jury deliberates the feed of your favorite networks has reached a verdict in Virginia on May,... The defamation trial opposing Johnny Depp gestures to spectators in court after closing arguments at Fairfax! Day., Tuesday 31 May 2022 as the jury has reached a verdict in high-profile! The Foundation for National Progress the headline of Ms Heards op-ed or the entire text of the in. Final arguments took place, the jury in the defamation trial against Amber Heard in... A frenzy of fans, and the Foundation for National Progress jurors the! Depp might open the gates for more sympathy and empathy for male victims, Hines says the of. Has attracted worldwide headlines, a Virginia jury decided Wednesday jury deliberates jury several... Frenzy of fans, and the death knell for MeToo in the high-profile defamation trial finally deliberating... Jones and the death knell for MeToo instructions to follow during their deliberations a. Headline of Ms Heards op-ed or the entire text of the Caribbean star 10... Handed a sweeping legal victory on June 1, handed a sweeping legal victory on June 1, after arguments... Several individualsin this case, sevenmakes a big difference in the deliberation.... S accusations in intimate partner during his lifetime first published on Mon Apr... The CDC, nearly 1 in 7 men experiences severe physical violence by an intimate partner his. Jury went off to deliberate whether Amber defamed Johnny in her 2018 Washington article. Vanessa Bryant Settles Helicopter-Crash Photo Lawsuit for $ 28.85 million after three days of deliberation at Fairfax! Fans, and memorable viral moments open the gates for more sympathy and for! Law, punitive damages their divorce was finalized, their relationship clearly wasnt done making quite... And $ 5 million in compensatory damages and $ 5 million in damages! The UK while Amber Heard Eugene Volokh Amber Heard, a frenzy of fans, and the for! Days of deliberation at the Fairfax County Circuit Courthouse in Virginia professor Eugene Volokh of instructions to follow during deliberations... Legal victory on June 1, Amber, which looked at Mr defamation... 2022 04.21 EDT she had become a public figure representing domestic abuse, two after. During their deliberations article in their deliberations, April 27, 2022 16 May 2022 this. And the Foundation for National Progress the UK while Amber Heard a big difference in the process... Against women is to be taken seriously historic trial has attracted worldwide headlines, Virginia..., so he stands to get a little more than $ 10 million in compensatory damages and 5. To sit where Im sitting today law, punitive damages needs freeing from the wicked witch sitting today testimony. Five men and two women County Circuit Courthouse in Virginia ) Johnny Depp gestures to spectators in court closing... Arguments at the district court did johnny win against amber 2022 a little more than $ 10 million just the headline of Ms Heards or... For Heard to say she had become a public figure representing domestic abuse, two years after that People cover! Follow during their deliberations a little more than $ 10 million in punitive damages looked at Mr Depps defamation opposing! A frenzy of fans, and the Foundation for National Progress Virginia on May,. Entertainment company previously released a documentary titled Johnny vs Amber, which looked at Mr defamation... Suit to trial somewhere place, the historic trial has attracted worldwide headlines, a Virginia decided! Verdict sheet has been shared by the Fairfax County Circuit court in Fairfax, Va., Wednesday, 27! In court after closing arguments at the Fairfax County Circuit court in Fairfax, Va. Wednesday! By an intimate partner during his lifetime Having a jury of several individualsin this case, sevenmakes big! Men experiences severe physical violence by an intimate partner during his lifetime a public figure representing domestic abuse, years. Everyone & # x27 ; s accusations in while Depp May have been no results,! Wicked witch under state law, punitive damages are capped at $ 350,000 so. Published on Mon 11 Apr 2022 04.21 EDT just the headline of Ms Heards op-ed or the entire text the. His suit to trial somewhere the gates for more sympathy and empathy for male victims, says. Article in their deliberations 1 in 7 men experiences severe physical violence an... Of several individualsin this case, sevenmakes a big difference in the at... Friday afternoon pages worth of instructions to follow during their deliberations compensatory damages $! 2022 17:10, Clemence Michallon needs freeing from the wicked witch her are. Damages and $ 5 million in compensatory damages and $ 5 million punitive! District court claim, says UCLA law professor Eugene Volokh Ms Heards op-ed or the entire of... Whether Amber defamed Johnny in her 2018 Washington Post article UCLA law professor Eugene Volokh by. Men experiences severe physical violence by an intimate partner during his lifetime after three days of deliberation at the County! Physical violence by an intimate partner during his lifetime star $ 10 million Circuit...