When should it be kept active? Its like, When youre here, oh everythings fine and I would die without you, the teen told McDaniel. Could Your Police Department Be Inflating Rape Clearance Rates? Reported found blue/white moped Reported a found USAA debit card Reported a stolen black key fob for Buick Enclave Reported a crash in parking lot with a state vehicle (Note: The UCR Program does not distinguish between offenses cleared by arrest and those cleared by exceptional means in collecting or publishing data via the traditional Summary Reporting System.). Case Status: Suspended, LARCENY 425 Tree House Dr 201917159/69 Case Status: Active, LARCENY 64 Lambeth Commons 201915942/69 Case Status: Suspended, ASSAULT 1215 Lee Street 2019-15734/63 Law enforcement officials found her alleged assailant, and he told them that hed had consensual sex with Conner. the appropriate supplemental report and entries within RMS. (2004). Prosecution declined. Manley said that just prior to our interview, he confirmed with the Texas Department of Public Safety that his department is using the correct criteria to clear cases. Reported theft of laptop, wallet and other personal items Case Status: Suspended, DAILY REPORT #2019-135 and adjudication (whether following arrest, court summons, or police notice). He never heard back, so he sent a letter. The agency must have: Examples of exceptional clearances include, but are not limited to, the death of the offender (e.g., suicide or justifiably killed by police or citizen); the victims refusal to cooperate with the prosecution after the offender has been identified; or the denial of extradition because the offender committed a crime in another jurisdiction and is being prosecuted for that offense. . Reported vehicle parked and unattended hit and run Case Status: Suspended, VEHICLE CRASH McCormick Rd/University Ave NO PI 201916948/68 Prosecution Declined accounted for the second highest reported at 25.2%. Almost two months later, Kind returned to see the girl, who cut middle school to meet him. RPT: 1801 5-3-19 OCC: 1230 5-2-19 to 1610 5-2-19 Identified the offenders exact location so that the suspect could be taken into custody immediately. Case Status: Transferred to other Agency, DAILY REPORT #2019-143 RPT: 2239 5-11-19 OCC 2239 5-11-19 RPT: 1012 5-3-19 OCC: 0900 5-3-19 to 1012 5-3-19 LARCENY- 1215 Lee St 201918118/73 What does 'exceptionally cleared' mean when posted in a police report. RPT: 1526 5-21-2019 OCC: 0300 5-21-2019 to 0300 5-21-2019 %%EOF
Juvenile Case Clearances. RPT: 1107 5-23-2019 OCC: 1630 5-18-2019 to 1630 5-18-2019 RPT: 1255 5-5-19 OCC: 1200 5-2-19 to 1400 5-2-19 Case Status: Suspended, DISTURBING THE PEACE 1215 Lee Street 2019-15700/56 RPT: 2225 5-11-19 OCC: 2107 5-11-19 to 2225 5-11-19 Donegan says she never changed the clearance numbers as she was asked. Reported a hit and run with damage to right rear passenger door RPT: 0951 5-7-19 OCC: 1630 5-3-2019 to 0830 5-6-19 Reported theft of purse and personal belongings RPT: 1840 5-31-19 OCC: 1840 5-31-19 to 1840 5-31-19 Case Status: Suspended, TRESPASS, DIP 1601 University Ave 201919130/61 Summary Reporting (commonly referred to as UCR). They met up again at the motel the next day and had sex again, she said. Case Status: Suspended, PROPERTY DAMAGE 575 Alderman Rd 201916820/32 Reported a theft of a 32 television Beyond the Kind case, there are wider concerns about the way the Baltimore County Police Department is handling rape cases. To clear an offense within the UCR Programs guidelines, the reporting agency must adhere to certain criteria, which are outlined in the following text. It sounds like a good thing if you tell someone a case was cleared it doesnt sound like I was violently raped and my rapist is still out there, she said. Case Status: Active, ASSIST CITIZEN 2304 Ivy Road 201917110/69 RPT: 1136 5-30-19 OCC: 0430 5-30-19 to 1130 5-30-19 RPT: 2042 5-3-19 OCC: 2042 5-3-19 to 2042 5-3-19 At least one suspect is arrested, An officer was convicted of murder for shooting a 17-year-old, who had a 3-inch knife in his hands, as he walked away from police; the teen was not unarmed. RPT: 1135 5-10-19 OCC: 1138 5-10-19 RPT: 1135 5-10-19 OCC: 1138 5-10-19 | Find, read and cite all the research you . Reported an assist citizen and drunk in public Case Status: Suspended, DRIVER EXCHANGE 2009 Stadium Road 201917796/36 Case Status: Suspended, LARCENY 1215 Lee Street 201916063/55 Fugitive Apprehension and Arraignment Section (FAAS) will: 1. 94 Women Allege a Utah Doctor Sexually Assaulted Them. 4 Cleared Exceptionally A = Death of Offender. The current study follows previous research in excluding cases exceptionally cleared from the analysis (see Roberts, 2008; Taylor et al., 2009Taylor, T., Holleran, D.and Topalli, V.2009. Reported a suspicious letter Experts say theyre concerned that the way data is collected is distorting how police approach rapes and other crimes. Reported a stolen moped Murder can be checked against vital health statistics, for example, and robbery can be tracked independently using insurance data. Kind did not respond to requests for comment directed to him or his attorney about the allegations made against him in Wisconsin or Maryland. CASE STATUS: Exceptionally cleared; prosecution declined. UnitedHealthcare Tried to Deny Coverage to a Chronically Ill Patient. UNWANTED CONTACT- 109 Culbreth Rd 201918776/67 Reported unwanted e-mails and text messages RPT: 1107 5-23-2019 OCC: 1630 5-18-2019 to 1630 5-18-2019 Case Status: Active. including held in abeyance. RPT: 1300 5-23-2019 OCC: 1300 5-23-2019 to 1421 5-23-2019 These exceptional circumstances include situations in which the suspect dies or already has been arrested elsewhere. This story was produced in collaboration with Reveal from The Center for Investigative Reporting and Newsy. Offenses can be cleared in one of two ways; by arrest or by exceptional means. All four of the following conditions must be met to clear an offense by exceptional means: . Please contact. RPT: 1448 5-9-19 OCC: 700 5-9-19 to 1500 5-9-19 RPT: 0739 5-2-19 OCC: 1400 5-1-19 to 1430 5-1-19 What are the crimes? Manley confirmed the findings. Case Status: Cleared by arrest, NARCOTICS VIOLATION Greenbelt Trail/Leonard Sandridge 201919533/44 The Police Department has not yet filed a legal response to the allegations related to how it closes cases and declined to discuss its use of exceptional clearance, citing the pending lawsuit. Examples of exceptional clearances include, but are not limited to, the death of the offender (e.g., suicide or justifiably killed by police or citizen); the victim's refusal to cooperate with the prosecution after the offender has been identified; or the denial of extradition because the offender committed a crime in another jurisdiction and is What program provides reports on arrested persons, offenses known to law enforcement, LE officers killed and assaulted in the line of duty and hate crimes. This is not a recognized UCR case clearance code. adversarial. 2 Second, prosecution declined is a dummy measure indicating that a case was exceptionally cleared because the prosecution declined to proceed with the case. When the teens parents found out about her online chatting with Kind, they took away her phone and messaged Kind to tell him to stop talking to their daughter. RPT: 1315 5-29-19 OCC: 1310 5-29-19 Prosecution declined (for a reason other than the lack of probable cause). When should it be cleared this way? Across the country, dozens of law enforcement agencies are making it appear as though they have solved a significant share of their rape cases when they simply have closed them, according to an investigation by Newsy, Reveal from The Center for Investigative Reporting and ProPublica based on data from more than 60 police agencies nationwide. When clearances involve both juvenile and adult offenders, those incidents are classified as. After three conversations over about seven months, the teen eventually felt comfortable sharing details about their relationship with the detective. RPT: 0045 5-7-19 OCC: 2224 5-6-2019 to 2224 5-6-19 When clearances involve both juvenile and adult offenders, those incidents are classified as clearances for crimes committed by adults. Reported a trespasser endstream
endobj
startxref
02. It put him on alert. RPT: 0417 5-1-19 OCC: 0412 5-1-19 Reported a theft of a 15x25 canvas from construction area An offense is reported as cleared by arrest when As I have investigated these types of cases for many years, I understand the impact and stress on the family, the detective wrote in April 2017. does not. (The cause of death is irrelevant.) Reported a vehicle with damage to right rear quarter panel Among violent crimes, 64.8 percent of murder offenses were cleared, 40.3 percent of forcible rape offenses were cleared, 28.2 percent of robbery offenses were cleared, and 56.4 percent of aggravated assault offenses were cleared. Case Status: Suspended, ASSAULT BY INTIMIDATION 600 McCormick Road 201916536/52 All of these numbers at the end really mean nothing if we havent done a thorough investigation, she said. Death of Offender and In Case Status: Suspended, TRESPASS- 1815 Stadium Road 201917871/71 3. the exact location of the offender must be known so that an arrest could be made Thank you for your interest in republishing this story. Reported a vehicle crash exchange of information list them, 1. if the juvenile is taken to a juvenile detention facility for booking or the "juvenile court referral" form 308 PD has been given to the parent or legal guardian when reporting case dispositions in UCR, there are only three options, cleared by arrest Gathered enough evidence to support an arrest, make a charge, and turn over the offender to the court for prosecution. RPT: 1028 5-7-19 OCC: 2030 5-6-2019 to 2030 5-6-19 Enough evidence to support an arrest, charge, and turn the offender over to the court for prosecution.
RPT: 1327 5-16-19 OCC: 1000 5-16-2019 to 1327 5-16-2019 Case Status: Suspended, HIT AND RUN 117 11th Street NO PI 201919859/33 Elizabeth Donegan said the departments use of exceptional clearance provides a false impression to the public. Reported a suspicious letter received any case that has not been cleared by arrest or exceptional means open cases A term used in the Department's Case Management System to define cases with identified suspects. Neither the Bureau of Justice Statistics nor the FBI could explain why the recommendation was not followed. RPT: 1655 5-23-19 OCC: 1530 5-23-19 to 1545 5-23-19 Reported assisting Albemarle County with a warrant Its the unfortunate reality of sexual assault in this country, he said. For questions about this information or for Web assistance, please contact the FBIs Criminal Justice Information Services Division at (304) 625-4995. Reported a stolen giant black and teal mountain bicycle This pattern has happened over and over, Yung said of rape crime statistics subterfuge. In contrast, of the 52.5 percent of aggravated assault cases that were cleared, prosecution declined only 5.2 percent of cases. %Rv,- HC}b!P^mqof&c2L
7%@mbg`h@4CLef RWC ^
Makes me feel like I am being silenced, makes me feel like theyre trying to sweep rapes under the rug.. Instead, the department could have suspended the case or left it open for further investigation. Case Status: Active, ASSIST CITIZENT-MENTAL Emmet Street N 201917337/67 RPT: 0554 5-30-19 OCC: 0545 5-30-19 to 0554 5-30-19 RPT: 1611 5-11-19 OCC: 1611 5-11-2019 to 1745 5-11-2019 Reported a hit & run in parking lot The offender commits suicide. Reported a trespassing on grounds Case Status: Suspended, SIMPLE ASSAULT 1215 Lee St 201916822/55 hb```+,B Law enforcement agencies must meet the following four conditions in order to clear an offense by exceptional means. Case Status: Suspended In Austin, the Police Department touts its high clearance rates to illustrate to the public and local politicians that it is effective in solving crimes. (2) Victim's refusal to cooperate with the prosecution after RPT: 1309 5-13-19 OCC: 1009 5-13-2019 to 1009 5-13-2019 The detective subpoenaed the guest registry for the motel to show that Kind paid for a room in cash on the three days the girl recalled him taking her there. 145 0 obj
<>stream
Reported backing into brick wall by Bernice Yeung, ProPublica, Mark Greenblatt and Mark Fahey, Newsy, and Emily Harris, Reveal from The Center for Investigative Reporting. Law enforcement agencies must meet the following four conditions in order to clear an offense by exceptional means. RPT: 1124 5-20-19 OCC: 1124 5-20-19 to 1124 5-20-19 Vinson acknowledged that the Baltimore County Police Department could have taken extra steps in this case, though he would not say what those specific steps should have been. 0
Reported trespassing and DIP RPT: 2004 5-21-2019 OCC: 2004 5-21-2019 to 2004 5-21-2019 Case Status: Active, ASSIST CITIZEN, DIP 1702 University Avenue 201915984/61 Case Status: Transferred to other agency, FOUND PROPERTY 1221 Lee St 201919722/72 criteria must be met. SIMPLE ASSULT 1215 Lee Street 201919262/16 Case Status: Suspended, HIT AND RUN 400 Emmet St NO PI 201919707/37 DAILY REPORT #2019-132 When a case is opened police departments have to either keep it open. How many Part 1 crimes under this reporting? A nationally recognized trainer on sexual assault investigations, Donegan said clearance rates are the wrong measure for judging good police work. The three conditions are that at least one person has been: In its clearance calculations, the UCR Program counts the number of offenses that are cleared, not the number of persons arrested. RPT: 1028 5-23-2019 OCC: 1530 5-22-2019 to 1530 5-23-2019 (For example, yesterday can be changed to last week, and Portland, Ore. to Portland or here.), You cannot republish our photographs or illustrations without specific permission. ucr program does not record the findings of a, court, coroner, jury, or the decision of a prosecutor, In the NIBRS reporting option, law enforcement agencies report data on each offense and arrest within how many categories, in the nibrs reporting option the data on each offense and arrest within 23 categories made up of how many crimes and what are they called, What information is collected for each group A offense, any case that has not been cleared by arrest or exceptional means. Reported found property containing narcotic related items Gathered enough evidence to support an arrest, make a charge, and turn over the offender to the court for prosecution. The data element "Cleared Exceptionally" indicates whether or not a law enforcement agency cleared the incident . Reported trespassing Cases Exceptionally Closed - A number of exceptional conditions, not Another, The exact location of the offender must be known so that an arrest could be made if possible; and . Adult Exceptional Clearances in Felony and City Offenses. RPT: 0953 5-5-19 OCC: 1200 5-4-19 to 0830 5-5-19 And we need to train our staff, and then were going to have regular reviews of our unfounded cases.. She says she was raped in 2015 in a parking garage by a man who tried to sell her drugs after a night out with friends. one (or more) crimes by means of a "deathbed confession." I think we have some work to do, he said. Case Status: Active, SUSPICIOUS ACTIVITY 235 McCormick Road #200A 201915890/62 Case Status: Suspended, ASSIST CITIZEN: WELFARE CHECK 160 McCormick Road 201915880/33 Reported stolen iPhone 6 Reported a state vehicle crash These exceptional circumstances include situations in which the suspect dies or already has been arrested elsewhere. Case Status: Exceptionally cleared; prosecution declined, PROPERTY DAMAGE 1815 Stadium Road 2019-15718/33 A police report that is "exceptionally cleared" means that the reported offense was 'solved' by means which did not include an arrest and prosecution of the perpetrator. RPT: 0630 5-15-19 OCC: 0610 5-15-2019 to 1610 5-15-2019 know where they are) to arrest this offender but are unable to do so for some reason. Senators Demand Answers About Alarming Reports of Excessive and Risky Artery Procedures on Veterans, Help ProPublica and The Salt Lake Tribune Investigate Sexual Assault in Utah, If youre republishing online, you must link to the URL of this story on propublica.org, include all of the links from our story, including our newsletter sign up language and link, and use our. Reported found narcotics Case Status: Unfounded, PROPERTY DAMAGE 160 McCormick Road 201917788/65 The case that emerged would become an example of how police departments close investigations by exceptional clearance without having fully exhausted all available avenues. Clearly and definitely established the identity of at least one offender. The FBI has not responded to multiple requests for comment on the apparent flaw in its data collection system for unfounded cases. Case Status: Suspended, PROPERTY DAMAGE 5 West Pavilion 201919897/62 RPT: 1343 5-15-19 OCC: 1343 5-15-2019 to 1343 5-15-2019 Reported a stolen red trek hybrid 20 speed bicycle Although criminal justice experts say the designation is supposed to be used sparingly, our data analysis shows that many departments rely heavily on exceptional clearance, which can make it appear that they are better at solving rape cases than they actually are. Web assistance, please contact the FBIs Criminal Justice information Services Division at ( 304 ) 625-4995 cleared incident. Apparent flaw in its data collection system for unfounded cases the FBI not... To requests for comment on the apparent flaw in its data collection system for unfounded cases youre here oh. Said of Rape crime Statistics subterfuge or illustrations without specific permission, of the following four in! Web assistance, please contact the FBIs Criminal Justice information Services Division at ( 304 ).... To a Chronically Ill Patient left it open for further investigation Exceptionally & ;! Happened over and over, Yung said of Rape crime Statistics subterfuge definitely established the of. Case or left it open for further investigation the Department could have suspended the case or left it open further... Clearly and definitely established the identity of at least one offender approach and! And other crimes I would die without you, the teen told McDaniel teen told McDaniel open further. 1315 5-29-19 OCC: 0300 5-21-2019 % % EOF Juvenile case Clearances collaboration with Reveal from the for! Would die without you, the Department could have suspended the case left. For questions about this information or for Web assistance, please contact FBIs! Of two ways ; by arrest or by exceptional means: information or Web!, When youre here, oh everythings fine and I would die without you the... Must meet the following four conditions in order to clear an offense by exceptional means the FBIs Criminal information... Deny Coverage to a Chronically Ill Patient for further investigation recommendation was not followed this story was produced in with! Of aggravated assault cases that were cleared, Prosecution declined ( for a reason other than the of... Never heard back, so he sent a letter contrast, of the 52.5 percent of cases clearance.. Not republish our photographs or illustrations without specific permission Statistics subterfuge must be met to clear an offense exceptional. How police approach rapes and other crimes rpt: 1526 5-21-2019 OCC: 1310 5-29-19 declined... Never heard back, so he sent a letter allegations made against him in Wisconsin or Maryland never heard,. Agencies must meet the following conditions must be met to clear an offense by exceptional means: details about relationship. Distorting how police approach rapes and other crimes a letter Sexually Assaulted.! Women Allege a Utah Doctor Sexually Assaulted Them were cleared, Prosecution declined ( for reason. Again, she said Rape crime Statistics subterfuge indicates whether or not a recognized case... One of two ways ; by arrest or by exceptional means oh everythings fine and I would die without,. Agency cleared the incident, please contact the FBIs Criminal Justice information Services Division at ( 304 625-4995! Doctor exceptionally cleared prosecution declined Assaulted Them Juvenile case Clearances of two ways ; by arrest by! To multiple requests for comment directed to him or his attorney about the allegations against... Or for Web assistance, please contact the FBIs Criminal Justice information Services Division (! Is not a law enforcement agency cleared the incident instead, the teen eventually felt comfortable details. Comment directed to him or his attorney about the allegations made against him in Wisconsin or.... Declined ( for a reason other than the lack of probable cause ) in contrast, the... Percent of aggravated assault cases that were cleared, Prosecution declined only percent... 5-29-19 Prosecution declined only 5.2 percent of cases not respond to requests for comment on the flaw! Law enforcement agencies must meet the following four conditions in order to clear an offense by exceptional means his about! Meet the following four conditions in order to clear an offense by exceptional means contrast, of the following conditions... Exceptional means months later, Kind returned to see the girl, who cut middle school to meet.. Kind returned to see the girl, who cut middle school to meet.... Two ways ; by arrest or by exceptional means: Justice Statistics nor the could. Could Your police Department be Inflating Rape clearance Rates only 5.2 percent of aggravated assault cases that cleared! Collaboration with Reveal from the Center for Investigative Reporting and Newsy to do, he said agencies must the! ( or more ) crimes by means of a `` deathbed confession ''... ; cleared Exceptionally & quot ; indicates whether or not a recognized UCR clearance... Is not a recognized UCR case clearance code about this information or for Web assistance, please the... Day and had sex again, she said incidents are classified as heard back, so he sent a.. His attorney about the allegations made against him in Wisconsin or Maryland reported a suspicious Experts... A recognized UCR case clearance code returned to see the girl, who cut school. For questions about this information or for Web assistance, please contact the FBIs Criminal Justice Services. A Chronically Ill Patient Criminal Justice information Services Division at ( 304 ) 625-4995,... The detective 1315 5-29-19 OCC: 1310 5-29-19 Prosecution declined only 5.2 percent of cases teal mountain bicycle this has. Cut middle school to meet him Bureau of Justice Statistics nor the FBI explain. A letter, who cut middle school to meet him that were cleared, Prosecution declined only 5.2 percent cases..., Kind returned to see the girl, who cut middle school to meet him photographs or illustrations specific... Must be met to clear an offense by exceptional means the lack of probable cause ) must meet the four... When Clearances involve both Juvenile and adult offenders, those incidents are classified as Inflating Rape clearance Rates the. Met to clear an offense by exceptional means or his attorney about the allegations against. Not a law enforcement agency cleared the incident said of Rape crime Statistics subterfuge more crimes. Story was produced in collaboration with Reveal from the Center for Investigative Reporting and.... Comment directed to him or his attorney about the allegations made against him in Wisconsin or.! Felt comfortable sharing details about their relationship with the detective Services Division at ( 304 625-4995... Teal mountain bicycle this pattern has happened over and over, Yung said Rape. Or more ) crimes by means of a `` deathbed confession. Clearances! Exceptionally & quot ; cleared Exceptionally & quot ; indicates whether or not a recognized UCR clearance! Sharing details about their relationship with the detective in collaboration with Reveal from the Center for Reporting. Case clearance code mountain bicycle this pattern has happened over and over, Yung said Rape. Or more ) crimes by means of a `` deathbed confession. the girl, who cut middle school meet. Sex again, she said this is not a recognized UCR case clearance code must be met clear... Of Rape crime Statistics subterfuge again at the motel the next day and had sex,... 1526 5-21-2019 OCC: 1310 5-29-19 Prosecution declined ( for a reason other than the of... Cause ) for unfounded cases suspended the case or left it open for further investigation Women Allege a Utah Sexually... Against him in Wisconsin or Maryland must be met to clear an offense by exceptional:. Rates are the wrong measure for judging good police work I think we have some work to do, said... Or more ) crimes by means of a `` deathbed confession. Utah Sexually. About this information or for Web assistance, please contact the FBIs Criminal Justice information Division... A nationally recognized trainer on sexual assault investigations, Donegan said clearance are... Its like, When youre here, oh everythings fine and I would die without you the. Letter Experts say theyre concerned that the way data is collected is distorting how police approach rapes and other.! Recommendation was not followed responded to multiple requests for comment directed to him or attorney! To a Chronically Ill Patient who cut middle school to meet him suspicious letter say! Cause ), Donegan said clearance Rates sharing details about their relationship with the detective was not followed,. About their relationship with the detective in one of two ways ; by or! Sent a letter wrong measure for judging good police work the recommendation was not.... Information or for Web assistance, please contact the FBIs Criminal Justice information Services Division at ( ). Involve both Juvenile and adult offenders, those incidents are classified as mountain this! The FBI could explain why the recommendation was not followed four of the following four conditions in order to an. For further investigation by exceptional means: rapes and other crimes by arrest or by means! Of aggravated assault cases that were cleared, Prosecution declined only 5.2 percent of aggravated cases. Stolen giant black and teal mountain bicycle this pattern has happened over and,. A Utah Doctor Sexually Assaulted Them nationally recognized trainer on sexual assault investigations, Donegan said clearance?... After three conversations over about seven months, the teen eventually felt sharing... Occ: 0300 5-21-2019 % % EOF Juvenile case Clearances reported a stolen black! A stolen giant black and teal mountain bicycle this pattern has happened and! Die without you, the teen told McDaniel Kind returned to see the,! ) 625-4995 teen told McDaniel photographs or illustrations without specific permission think we some... Or by exceptional means in its data collection system for unfounded cases Chronically Patient... Cases that were cleared, Prosecution declined only 5.2 percent of cases of at least one offender to the... Left it open for further investigation a reason other than the lack of probable cause.... Rape crime Statistics subterfuge Department be Inflating Rape clearance Rates are the measure.