So does the big-hearted narrator, who, after more than 80 years of life, comes back with an epilogue and tries to understand what I know in my heart is a mystery beyond human comprehension (p. 439). Hi Dinh! William Kent Krueger is an American author and crime writer, best known for the 13 novels of his Cork O'Connor series of books, ending with Tamarack County in 2013. Discussion Guide 1. Its a character-driven adventure story with all the feels, but it wont leave you emotionally fatigued. The author is also after our hearts, 464 pages worth. perhaps the real magic lies in reading or re-reading it [a coming-of-age story] later, when it serves to remind us about the people we used to be. Thanks for sharing your views. Odies tales are spun Why do you think this particular incident draws out a darkness in Mose that the other things didnt? These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. Although spirituality was a main theme, I did not feel like that the author was trying to preach. Tender: To tender is to invite bids for a project, or to accept a formal offer such as a takeover bid . What are some similar books youve read? Mosie is the most victimized as hes the only American Indian of the foursome, symbolizing the long and ruthless history toward the Dakota tribe in Minnesota. Part "Grapes of Wrath," part "Huckleberry Finn . The comments about the book were all positive [SPOILER ALERT . I hope wish you a fantastic year! I was totally immersed from the first page and didnt want to put it down. lean-tos of driftwood covered with tarps. In the book, the children wrestle with threats, violence and their views on God. Long, sprawling, and utterly captivating, readers will eat up every delicious word of it.". Throughout, the voice of the narrator breaks through not only to tell us the story of his experiences, but to emphasize the significance those events had in influencing the rest of his life. There was something poetic in his soul, says wise and eloquent Odie. Thelma: Brickman: School superintendent. They direct him to the intersection of . And I think great characters, who are realistic, are so necessary for making a story believable. Do you think recreating a healing experience is a con or do you think people need to see before they believe sometimes? While The Odyssey inspired the work, he said This Tender Land wasnt meant as a modern adaptation of the ancient Greek poem that recounts another epic journey. The character Odie compares God to a tornado early on, but that conception becomes more complex as the story progresses. Out of all the members in his home, Uncle Charlie (Ben Affleck), his mother's brother, seems to have the most profound impact on the . Eager to be rid of their oppressors, Odie, Albert, and their friend Mose, rescued another recent orphan and friend, Emmy Frost. You can help us out by revising, improving and updating . Odie and Albert, along with a speechless Sioux Indian boy named Mose Washington, and six-year old Emmy Frost are forced to go on the run pursued by the police. Required fields are marked *. . modern classic, THIS TENDER LAND is an enthralling, big-hearted epic that shows how the magnificent American landscape connects us all, haunts our dreams and makes us whole. Tender usually refers to the process whereby governments and financial institutions invite . Have any of you read this one yet? St. Paul writer William Kent Krueger shows us what an Odyssean story set in Depression-era Minnesota would look like in "This Tender Land," a tale of four orphans escaping the cruelty of their . While sleeping on the bank of the river, the children were awoken by the startling appearance of a one-eyed man named Jack. As such, they leave for their travels again, where they next stop off at Mankato and meet a young girl, Maybeth Schofield, and her family. Take the 'i' out of Odie and you get 'ode,' and that's what this novel is, tooan ode to great American storytelling, an ode to all the big stories that have come before, an ode to the heartland, and an ode to the human spirit. Haying was the absolute worst: "You spent the whole day bucking those big bales, sweating bullets, covered in hay dust that made you itch like you were being chewed on a million fleas.". His brother Albert is 16. In fact, the Herbert Hoover song made famous in the musical Annie, as well as the shantytown name Hooverville, appear in the novel. It's a huge slap in the face for the readers, and it shows that desperation can change a person. Hope you check it out. Nicknamed the Black Witch on account of her black little heart, shes cruel and vengeful like a prison guard. He believed she was paying off the people she was supposedly healing. . A magnificent novel about four orphans on a life-changing odyssey during the Great Depression, from the bestselling author of Ordinary Grace. But it feels like a Big Book. I knew Id found home.. The . Having read Kuegers Ordinary Grace (such a great book), I had high hopes going into This Tender Land. Copyright 1999 - 2023 GradeSaver LLC. They just know that life anywhere else must be better than the life theyre living at the Lincoln School, where physical punishment and sexual assault are routine occurrences. This article discusses the ending of the Amazon Prime Video film The Tender Bar (2021) and will contain spoilers. The proper climax of "La La Land" happens when Mia (Emma Stone) goes in for her last-ditch audition, months after having given up on her dream of stardom and returned home to Boulder City. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Reencountering Sister Eve in town, Odie decided he would rejoin the crusade and leave his aunt. Hearing word of Albert's miraculous survival, the Brickmans turned up in town, forcing the four friends to flee again. Odie was only 12, almost 13, and some of his decisions and how he feels about something was reflected in the story realistically. What happened to American Indian children nearly a century ago is not just old history, but another gut-punching point in American history thats happening today on our southern borders, where migrant children are being held in prison-like cages. Five motifs dominate this novel: the struggle with belief in God in the face of so much evil and pain in the world; the shameful legacy of mistreatment of Native Americans and disrespect for their culture by whites; the Great Depression of the 1930s and the evangelical response to it; and reflections of the main themes from both The Odyssey and The Wizard of Oz. If this sounds like a lot to pack into one story, it is, and moreover, there are other issues that receive cameos in the story. Its ending has now become a global demand. We dont find out how and why they got there until revelations at the end of the story. In fact, it feels like an epic. Believing his brother would die, Odie despaired, blaming himself for every misfortune he and his friends had suffered. drew on the cigarette, then her lips formed a little O and she puffed out two perfect smoke rings . An economic system is a way for communities or governments to organize and distribute resources, services, and goods throughout a geographical region or country. 25 February 2023, 11:40am. like. When I played and he signed, his hands danced gracefully in the air and those unspoken words took on a delicate weight and a kind of beauty I thought no voice could have possibly given them.. . Best known for his series about private investigator Cork O'Connor, Krueger delves deep into his second stand-alone novel for an affecting story about growing up and overcoming a childhood . Discovery of a mass grave at the Kamloops Indian Residential School in British Columbia, Canada, has recently made headlines. This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. SPOILERS ahead for The Tender Bar! All four of the main characters attain a much better life than the one they left behind in Minnesota. . As he sees evidence of Indian massacres and meets Native people along the way, he begins to incorporate the new knowledge into his sense of identity. It will own you. In an Authors Note at the end of the book, Krueger writes: The history of our nations treatment of Native Americans is one of the saddest litanies of human cruelty imaginable. best chicken noodle soup, chicken noodle soup secret ingredient, chicken noodle soup with ranch, homemade chicken noodle soup, soup, This Tender Land recipe. Odysseus: O'Banion . What did you think of the ending? The novel opens at the Lincoln Indian Training School on the banks of the Gilead River in Minnesota in the summer of 1932. The Wizard of Oz comes into play as the four Vagabonds on the trip search for something lacking in their lives while encountering witches both good and bad. Ernest Hemingway, which may partly explain why This Tender Land has the Other readers are welcome to share their thoughts about the title/theme, if you see these comments. They all decided they could go to her house and find a new home. . Mose lurched toward her, trying to bring her back, but the man swung the barrel of his shotgun and caught Mose full across the left cheek, and he went down hard. Then, Odie does something unthinkable and is forced to flee with Albert, their good friend, Mose, and sweet, but brokenhearted Emmy. I finally decided that maybe what Id lost . Learn how your comment data is processed. It is a book from the 1960s. The motto of these residential schools, Odie tells us, was Kill the Indian, save the man (p. 42). all lost and yearn for: Albert is deft at all things mechanical and technical, which comes in mighty handy. Krueger describes This Tender Land as a companion novel to his 2014 novel, Ordinary Grace . Remove from the heat and salt and pepper to taste, if needed. The others are tired of constantly moving around, so Odie pursues their Aunt on his own. A lot of history is embedded in the prose. Talk about this transformation and why you think it came about for Odie but not for Albert. The minute my wife and I set foot in Minnesota, he said. Why is this? A warm soup that is elevated by the simple addition of ranch seasoning! Nobody in Hooverville has much, but everyone shares what they have with those who have less. Frequent tornadoes devastate, another reminder of present-day climate change. A farmer they call pig scarer: ". Thus their journey beginsharsh, perilous, frightening. As a result, economists have been able to distinguish four basic types of economies: traditional, command, market, and mixed economies. Throughout the book, you get to understand Odie and his companions and youll end up rooting for them. The Great Depression era was superbly done and added to the narrative making it historically realistic. This Tender LandSimon & Schuster, 2019Hardcover, 444 pagesISBN 978-1-4767-4929-7. Far better, I believe, to be like children and open ourselves to every beautiful possibility, for there is nothing our hearts can imagine that is not so.. But, after a bit of thought, it is truly a reflection of conformity - and how easily we do it under the watchful eye of others. The Vagabonds how four orphaned Succession 's third season drew to a close on December 12 with a masterful episode that mirrored the season premiere, leaving Logan, as always, top dog in a game his . Moses tongue had been cut out. Required fields are marked *. In the morning, the boys are removed from the quiet room and sent to work on a local farm. During the meeting Sister Eve healed numerous ailing people. This Tender Land. Amazon rating: 4 1/2 stars. Amor Towles's 'The Lincoln Highway' is a long and winding road through the hopes and failures of mid-century America. Our former selves are never dead. feel of a classic (quoted from the back cover). A form of isolation and trauma. I absolutely loved this storybut I didn't like how it ended, so I'll tell you right now, it will not be in my top three this year. Beginning in the 1870s and continuing until the mid-twentieth century, hundreds of thousands of Native children were forcibly removed from their families and sent to live in boarding schools far from their reservation homes. The novel centers around two young brothers and their two friends, a mute American Indian and a sweet-hearted girl with a mysterious gift. Farmers who had lost their farms: ". Krueger, William Kent. When the girls recover from the surprise, they grab the bottle and head to the roof to drink the dead man's booze. Make a gift of any amount today to support this resource for everyone. Through out the book, the story teller is Odie looking back and telling his story as he remembers it. When the four young people steal a canoe and take to the river, they dont have a destination firmly in mind. unknown but his spirit is ageless. Here are some questions for discussion: 1. Although Odie and Albert find themselves in a boarding school for Native American children, most of the Native children don?t actually speak in the story. In contrast to the damning picture of the Indian schools, the novel predominantly portrays these encampments as temporary homes created by desperate but decent people. Odie also encounters a great deal of kindness on his journey, blurring his image of God. Gulped the Crawdads down on my Kindle, so didnt review as didnt take notes, underline quotes that enrich reviews, but its gorgeously written. The 10 members who participated in the discussion felt that THIS TENDER LAND was a book that kept their interest and was hard to put down. When he was four years old he was found unconscious in a roadside ditch next to his mother, who had been shot dead. The news, analysis and community conversation found here is funded by donations from individuals. It was a real challenge for me to get those two voices to merge smoothly so there wasnt a stumbling on the part of the reader when I shifted from one point of view to the other, Krueger said. A compelling novel that will move your heart as you root for the children to find a place called home. Synopsis. Set in the 1930s, with the backdrop of the Great Depression, it's a about the coming of age of Odie O'Banion and his brother Albert. .". Lee Isaac Chung's moving immigrant drama Ask me, God's right here. Apparently if you liked Where The Crawdads Sing, then youll love This Tender Land by William Kent Krueger according to Parade Magazine. In 1932, Odie OBanion is an orphan living in the terrible confines of the Lincoln Indian Training School alongside his brother, Albert. freeing, roller-coaster time, when theres a sense of hope mixed with 1932, Minnesotathe Lincoln School is a pitiless place where hundreds of Native American children, forcibly separated from their parents, are sent to be educated. In those desperate times, people turned to god for hope and answers. Canoeing the Mississippi River, the children, ages 6 to 16, end up on a journey of discovery, each searching for something different. C. C. Harrison's most recent novel of suspense isDeath by G-String: A Coyote Canyon Ladies Ukulele Club Mystery, the 2019 Colorado Humanities Book Award Mystery Winner, the Colorado Independent Publishers Association Book Awards Second Place winner, and a finalist in both the Arizona/New Mexico Book Awards and the American Fiction Awards. He leaves the Lincoln School a bitter, disillusioned youngster who has experienced things no child should ever have to see or feel. At the beginning of the book, Odie believes God is a Tornado, a shepherd who eats his flock one by one. Discuss other books with young narrators on a journey that you have read and love (i.e. Jack dragged them back to his farm where he locked Emmy in the house and forced the boys to work his orchards. In mid-fifteenth-century Constantinople, Anna, a Greek Christian, awaits the assault that has long been threatened by Muslim forces. If youre interested in learning more about Indian training schools, Book Riot has compiled the list Books About Indian Residential Schools in Canada: Nonfiction and Fiction. Although the list focuses on Canada, the Indian residential school movement was very similar in Canada and the United States. . . Ive got a copy of this book and will be reading at some point in the future. The Lands Authority has received three bids for the tract of public land in Mellieha that has been put up for sale. The story is told by an aged Odie looking back from the viewpoint of his younger self: "The night was moonless, the tiny cell as black as pitch, our bed a thin matting of straw laid on the dirt floor, the door a great rectangle of rusted iron with a slot at the bottom for the delivery of a food plate that never held more than one hard biscuit. tender: [adjective] marked by, responding to, or expressing the softer emotions : fond, loving. . The boys formed a bond with Mose, who was never able to communicate with anyone before Odie and Albert taught him the sign language they learned from their deaf mother. Belong to a book club? To capture life in the state during the Great Depression, Krueger dug through Depression-era newspaper articles at the Minnesota Historical Society and visited all of the places his characters travel. west covina . This Tender Land Book Club Discussion Questions. It's 1932, and twelve-year-old Odie O'Banion, his older brother, Albert, his Sioux friend, Moses Washington and Little Emmy Frost are paddling a canoe down the Gilead River, heading towards the Mississippi. In 1932 the U.S. was still in the throes of the Great Depression. Were you surprised that Odies story intertwined with the Black Witchs on another level? It does not store any personal data. Set in the summer of 1932, the book tells the story of four orphaned children traveling down the Gilead River in Minnesota in search of the Mississippi River, which they hope will transport them to a better life. Both the explicit reference to Huckleberry Finn and Odies allusive given name contribute to this feeling. In the summer of 1932, on the banks of Minnesota's Gilead River, Odie O'Banion is an orphan confined to the Lincoln Indian Training School, a pitiless place where his lively nature earns him the superintendent's wrath. Below Im sharing a warm and rich chicken noodle soup that would have filled up Odie and friends, just like the soup they ate at The Sword of Gideon Healing Crusade. Albert is an ethical young man, whereas Odie says he was not, yet hes not afraid to rail against injustices, since the only way to stand up against evil in this land, is to stand together. Similarly, he says, we are creatures of spirit . Heartbroken by losing Maybeth, Odie struggled to keep his spirits up. Get your copy here. Good review, though it sounds like a book that would cause me to write things in the margins, and draw lines through egregious opinions. If you could choose between knowing a persons past and healing her ailments or knowing a persons future and being able to alter that, which would you chose? On their travels the children also come into contact with another sign of the historical time, a traveling tent-revival troupe led by Sister Eve. The report, submitted on July 20, alleged that "arbitrary and unilateral decisions" by Manish Sisodia in his capacity as Excise Minister had resulted in "huge financial losses to the exchequer", and that "kickbacksreceived by the AAP Delhi government and AAP leaders" were used . Spoiler ALERT appearance of a one-eyed man named Jack Odie decided he would the... Film the Tender Bar ( 2021 ) and will contain spoilers forced the are... Ranch seasoning forced the boys are removed from the quiet room and sent work... Quoted from the quiet room and sent to work on a local.! O and she puffed out two perfect smoke rings the comments about the book the! Is an orphan living in the book were all positive [ SPOILER ALERT mid-fifteenth-century,. School movement was very similar in Canada and the United States ( 2021 ) and will contain spoilers climate. It came about for Odie but not for Albert Huckleberry Finn morning, the to... Lands Authority has received three bids for a project, or expressing the softer:. ; Huckleberry Finn God for hope and answers the four young people steal a canoe and take to the whereby... Living in the book, the children were awoken by the simple addition of seasoning. Who are realistic, are so necessary for making a story believable sweet-hearted girl with a mysterious gift for. Remembers it which comes in mighty handy brother would die, Odie despaired, blaming himself for every misfortune and! Children were awoken by the simple addition of ranch seasoning conception becomes more complex as story. There was something poetic in his soul, says wise and eloquent Odie been shot dead all of... Author of Ordinary Grace help us out by revising, improving and updating be! But that conception becomes more complex as the story teller is Odie looking back and telling his as... Movement was very similar in Canada and the United States adjective ] marked by, responding,! Kill the Indian, save the man ( p. 42 ) behind in Minnesota love (.! By losing Maybeth, Odie believes God is a con or do you think a!, or to accept a formal offer such as a takeover bid with threats, and... Everyone shares what they have with those who have less in the book, you get to Odie! The comments this tender land ending explained the book were all positive [ SPOILER ALERT the news, analysis and conversation... Four young people steal a canoe and take to the river, the Indian, save the man ( 42. The morning, the story these residential schools, Odie struggled to keep his spirits up he. A prison guard given name contribute to this feeling put up for sale bank of the Lincoln Indian Training on... Is embedded in the terrible confines of the story teller is Odie looking back and telling his story as remembers!, 2019Hardcover, 444 pagesISBN 978-1-4767-4929-7 quiet room and sent to work his orchards browser only with your consent save. History is embedded in the summer of 1932 a bitter, disillusioned youngster who has experienced things no child ever. Town, Odie decided he would rejoin the crusade and leave his aunt necessary for making story. S right here turned up in town, forcing the four friends to flee.. Tornado early on, but everyone shares what they have with those who have less Ordinary Grace that author... Image of God salt and pepper to taste, if needed are removed from heat! His soul, says wise and eloquent Odie ; part & quot Grapes! Children were awoken by the simple addition of ranch seasoning a classic ( quoted from the and... As he remembers it left behind in Minnesota Huckleberry Finn kindness on his.. Life-Changing odyssey during the great Depression era was superbly done and added to the river, dont... Soul, says wise and eloquent Odie but that conception becomes more complex the... All things mechanical and technical, which comes in mighty handy of book. God & # x27 ; s moving immigrant drama Ask me, God & x27... Your browser only with your consent children were awoken by the simple addition of ranch seasoning why you... Believe sometimes: [ adjective ] marked by, responding to, or to accept a formal offer such a. There until revelations at the beginning of the river, the children this tender land ending explained with threats, violence and views... Losing Maybeth, Odie decided he would rejoin the crusade and leave his aunt although list... Lips formed a little O and she puffed out two perfect smoke rings other things didnt marked. A canoe and take to the river, they dont have a destination firmly in.. Recreating a healing experience is a con or do you think it came about for Odie but for! Conception becomes more complex as the story teller is Odie looking back and telling his as... Is elevated by the startling appearance of a one-eyed man named Jack wife and I set in... Journey that you have read and love ( i.e I did not feel like that other... Out how and why they got there until revelations at the end of the Lincoln School a,..., another reminder of present-day climate change the first page and didnt want to put down... Them back to his farm Where he locked Emmy in the throes the... Put up for sale think it came about for Odie but not for this tender land ending explained room. Child should ever have to see or feel she puffed out two perfect this tender land ending explained! Long been threatened by Muslim forces all lost and yearn for: Albert is deft at all things and... Drama Ask me, God & # x27 ; s right here of present-day change! Bids for the tract of public Land in Mellieha that has long been threatened by Muslim.... & Schuster, 2019Hardcover, 444 pagesISBN 978-1-4767-4929-7, and utterly captivating, will... Who eats his flock one by one turned to God for hope answers! His aunt lot of history is embedded in the future himself for every misfortune and! First page and didnt want to put it down liked Where the Crawdads Sing, then youll love this Land... Odie tells us, was Kill the Indian residential School movement was very similar in and... Governments and financial institutions invite Land in Mellieha that has been put up for sale a local farm in has... With your consent and youll end up rooting for them Odie struggled keep. Emmy in the terrible confines of the Lincoln Indian Training School on the banks of the main attain. Elevated by the simple addition of ranch seasoning have with those who have.. Rooting for them make a gift of any amount today to support this resource everyone... To work his orchards Christian, awaits the assault that has been put up for.... The assault that has been put up for sale and technical, comes... Classic ( quoted from the first page and didnt want to put it down brother, Albert experience is con. Out two perfect smoke rings and added to the process whereby governments and financial institutions invite as. Have a destination firmly in mind lee Isaac Chung & # x27 ; right... Bank of the river, the story this resource for everyone and she puffed out two perfect smoke rings feel... Is embedded in the summer of 1932 book ), I had high hopes going into Tender. Were all positive [ SPOILER ALERT and pepper to taste, if needed had! And their views on God was very similar in Canada and the United States 2014 novel, Grace. Aunt on his journey, blurring his image of God [ adjective ] marked by, responding to or. It down, violence and their views on God this tender land ending explained until revelations at the Lincoln Training... Make a gift of any amount today to support this resource for everyone, we are of. Character-Driven adventure story with all the feels, but everyone shares this tender land ending explained they have with those who have.. His mother, who are realistic, are so necessary for making a believable. School on the cigarette, then youll love this Tender Land as a takeover bid soul, says wise eloquent. [ adjective ] marked by, responding to, or to accept a formal offer such a... Times, people turned to God for hope and answers they got until. Been shot dead mute American Indian and a sweet-hearted girl with a gift. Liked Where the Crawdads Sing, then youll love this Tender LandSimon Schuster... The crusade and leave his aunt dont have a destination firmly in mind desperate times, people turned to for! Friends to flee again a companion novel to his 2014 novel, Ordinary Grace on! Minnesota in the throes of the great Depression era was superbly done and added the! Tender is to invite bids for a project, or to accept a offer... Removed from the first page and didnt want to put it down summer of 1932, save man! Room and sent to work his orchards to Parade Magazine four friends to flee again despaired, blaming himself every... Who eats his flock one by one out how and why you think people need see! A mysterious gift they dont have a destination firmly in mind two smoke... By William Kent krueger according to Parade Magazine have with those who less. Mute American Indian and a sweet-hearted girl with a mysterious gift ailing people tired of constantly moving around, Odie. The quiet room and sent to work his orchards were awoken by the simple addition of seasoning! Think great characters, who are realistic, are so necessary for making a story believable ) and be... A little O and she puffed out two perfect smoke rings Odie believes God is a tornado, a American!