I would say that this is rather accurate in its analysis of Pinocchio. It makes me want to look at all those people who say, Oh, Pinocchio is the sweetest little Disney classic and say, Youre new here, right? Compared to the stuff you outlined here, Hunchback of Notre Dame is downright tame. Anyone else find it disturbing? He wishesthat his puppet would come to life. Never trust them or expose yourself to their works if you value your soul and your joy for living. Beautiful! Naturally, he is first easily fooled by Honest John, but dont forget Jimmy warned him against going with John and told him exactly what to say to get out of the situation. Pinocchio isnt the only film that has the villain not getting his comeuppance. I am quite surprised because I personally LOVE Pinocchio but I have a friend who does dislike it. . Unselfish? Hell even lock away people he knows arent really crazy for money (and he loves it). The threat to be made into firewood was certainly there. Is it impossible that a street rat can trick a mad sorcerer into becoming a genie by taking advantage of his pride? I am SHOCKED. He is lured away by Mr. Measures 3-1/4" x 7-3/8". She is the definition of a Deus ex Machina. Also, at the end, it seems everyone interprets Pinocchio as having died when I had thought it was just knocked unconscious or maybe a coma. He wants to please her. Daria and the Clichd Representation of Teenagers, How Princesses of Color Have Improved the Disney Princess Narrative. Good point. Pinocchio is the only Disney movie to do this. She is the benevolent solution and in so doing, provided Pinocchio with the rebirth he needed (notice his donkey ears and tail are gone) and he is set to live happily ever after. A plump man in a red suit spills piles of gold provided Honest John gets him stupid little boys to take to a place called Pleasure Island, a place John implies is illegal, fearing the law might come after them. When the movie starts, it begins with the famous When you Wish Upon a Star sequence and skip to Gepetto finishing his latest wooden creation. However, Pinocchios time with Stomboli soon turns sour when Pinocchio is locked in a cage, which he is freed from by Jiminy Cricket. 17 of the biggest differences Disney's live-action 'Pinocchio' makes from the animated movie. It is implied to be an illegal theme park, hinted by Honest John during the meeting in the Inn. A good break from diagnosing the intent of every action an influential person makes. Pleasure Island was an area of the Downtown Disney shopping, dining and entertainment district at Walt Disney World Resort. Pinocchio came on the Disney channel today and I am literally here watching Pinocchio for the first time in years, with my five year old daughter. The one who promised she would never help him again. Pinocchio was trapped, tripped, sent to the theater, used, abused, and locked up. She is currently based in Wisconsin, USA. And you notice that Pinocchio also has it more difficult than other Disney protagonists in a certain way. Many pedophiles never act on and go to great difficulties to overcome these attractions, and must face the status of assumed child molester that misuses of the term exactly like this create for them. I havent seen Pinocchio since I was probably 8 and Im 37 now but its surprising how I instantly recollected the scenes you were describing. The way the movie teases this is very unnerving with a frustrated Jiminy storming away from Pinocchio and Lampwick and discovering the once bright, lively island to be empty. The Coachman got away with slavery and possible pedophilia and murder. The circus exploiting him..the people making fun. Great article by the way, I really enjoyed reading it , **I meant to say Pinocchio tries to blame Honest John and Stromboli to the blue Fairy.. sure they WERE monsters, but he was sort of saying nothing was his fault so he was lying and his nose grew. Remaking an animated film in live-action implies framing the tale in a more realistic light. You would think, in that case, that when given the chance to redoor better yet, altogether eliminatethis traumatic movie moment, Disney might dial down the horror. However, probably the scariest moment comes when the movie shows Lampwicks drawn-out painful transformation. The injustices towards animals are as real and now as they were then. I shouldve added that. Free shipping for many products! They do not know what exactly Pleasure Island has in store for him, but they are alarmed by a menacing Coachman who persuades them to bring him disobedient boys. Gepetto is a weirdo and people probably know that. All hopes that director Robert Zemeckis would simply skip over the donkey stuff in this remake were dashed when the CGI Pinocchio followed his misbehaving friend Lampwick (played by Lewin Lloyd) to the hedonistic Pleasure Island. You honestly dont call that distinguished or successful? This is just sad. They can eat whatever they want, drink whatever they want, ice cream, dil pickles, beer, cigarettes, cigars, picking fights for the fun of it, destruction all of them were mentioned explicitly. Youd be hard-pressed to find a more horrifying moment in Disney cinematic history than the donkey scene in the animated 1940 Pinocchio movie. Tragic enough when looked at on the surface, more so when one looks under the dark coat. 13. Thankfully, Pinocchio swears to never lie again and the Fairy forgives but warns that this would be the last time she could help. 1.Honestly your 100% right pinocchio is dark and based on child abduction and pedophilia but yes Pedophilia is probably gonna be normal for the next 50-70 years and It was actually widely practiced in ancient cultures and a lot of religious figures from all Abraham in religion are pedophiles. The very night the Blue Fairy gives life to Pinocchio, Geppetto tucks him into bed, because he has to go to school tomorrow. Pinocchio manages to escape this fate, though his friend Lampwick is transformed. Kids found something to be scared of adults found something else, including but not limited to slavery and pedophilia. Holly likes consuming a variety of types of media, although she adores sitcoms, Mad Men, Indiana Jones, and Star Wars in particular, and she is excited to share that love with readers! Punishment for evil doers need no be explicitly observed ,for there is just compensation that we all must face. Seems that they were telling us all along. When Pinocchio lies about why he didnt go to school, I think he does it to get out of trouble. Even Hunchback had the decency togive a showy happy ending with singing and dancing for all of Paris after the fiery, infernal battle with Judge Claude Frollo. Early Disney films were seriously dark. Wow, I stumbled on to this inside Snapchat as a link from some random story, and just read the entire thing and every comment. To see this, every last truth, lie, lesson, virtue and villain Pinocchio has to offer must be examined. The sense of tragedy/loss/exploitation in Dumbo and injustice/darkness in Pinocchio drag viewers into affects they might not have expected in a Disney film. ::::shudders:::: Now I get why!! As he sits on the beach, recovering from his painful ordeal, he gets a message from a dove sent by none other than the Blue Fairy. Explore the latest videos from hashtags: #pleasureisland, #pineappleisland, #pineislandsound, #peleisland . Yeah but think about it this way the story was not about defeating evil it was about staying away from it or if you do indulge in it consequences will follow. The biggest driving force behind the plot of Disney+s Pinocchio is the Blue Fairys promise to turn Pinocchio into a human child if he is able to remain true, brave, and unselfish. It would have also been fascinating to read some analysis about the themes of responsibility and accountability which are some key themes of Pinocchio. This is the first time in the movie that Pinocchio turned down temptation and misbehavior, which is something that the other children were not able to do. What's the over/under on Geppetto living long enough to see Pinocchio make his own little Pinocchios? Jiminy Cricket (Cliff Edwards) tries his best to be Pinocchio's moral compass, but he's not exactly an . At the beginning of the first film, we learn of Lord Farquaad's ban of all fairytale creatures. My dad absolutely despises Pinocchio, in large part because it was such a dark film. now of course when youre little you have no idea what the F is going on, but you just get scared. It means a lot. If you read the origins of why Sesame Street ended the gag of the adults not believing Big Bird about Snuffy, it implies that most kids would WANT TO tell their parents about an experience they were scarred from, because the gag was making kids think that nobody would believe them when they were telling the truth (which Pinocchio promised earlier in the movie to always do). In her personal life, she is also an avid video game enthusiast and amateur Super Smash Bros. player and she occasionally participates in her local Smash competitive scene. In this fascinating feature, culled from story meetings between February 1938 and July 1939 (the film would eventually be released in February of 1940), Walt. Honest John once again lures the gullible Pinocchio into a trap by giving him the false diagnosis that he is ill and in need of a vacation to Pleasure Island. Pinocchio goes to Pleasure Island with Lampwick, a place with "no school, no cops" and it's all free. That's not necessarily the case with Pinocchio. Pleasure Island is both a confession and a boast. wow wow wow. And this symbolizes the completion of his quest. Wood? Unless you're not a peer. Once again, Honest John and Gideon are involved, this time convincing Pinocchio to go on vacation to Pleasure Island despite knowing dreadful consequences await him there. The most obvious is that he is swallowed by the whale Monstro and burped back up, a clear allusion to Jonah and the whale which is a clear allusion to Jesus and his resurrection. Warning: There are spoilers ahead for Disney's "Pinocchio" remake, which is now streaming on Disney+. Even if he would have wanted to escape, they wouldnt have let him!! Its an interesting piece of the Disney canon. And without the fun, there's really nothing for him to learn. Theres also a 1970 animated version which is really good. Usually the bad guy always gets it in the end. Pleasure Island is an amusement park located on an island, where it is accessed by ferry . What was it Jiminy said about a conscience? It's very odd. Stromboli keeps on doing what he's doing. I taught a Disney Films class last year and my students (18-adult) HATED Pinocchio and Dumbo with equal vigor. Until the Blue Fairy decides to resurrect him as a real boy, flesh and blood. In fact, it is a sort of truth. He sneers, What do I look like, a jackass?. Are you just saying that or has there ever been accusations or suspicious events around ole Walt that would point to that possibility. 560 Views. Thank you for that. Pedophilia does tend to scar the victim for life. Good essay, but I suggest you be more accurate when referring to things such as pedophilia. ** Never one to shy away from darkness, del Toros version is said to be an intentionally darker take on the story, and may well capture the tone of Collodis novel closer than any other adaptation. Pleasure Island is an amusement park where kids can do whatever they want. 'Yellowstone' Return Date Info, When Does The Next New Episode of 'Yellowstone' Air on Paramount Network? Quick summary: Pinocchio is lured by the bad foxes, gets sold to a guy in entertainment biz, he escapes, lured by foxes again, then sold to a guy who is going to take him to "pleasure island" (yes, that's the real name of island in movie). (The 1940 Pleasure Island was awash in cigars and liquor; now Pinocchio shrinks from root beer and a pool game.) After turning down their offer, Pinocchio loses his donkey ears and tail. I have friends who didnt see the Hunchback till later too. He uses that rather underhanded tactic to try and ruin George Bailey, and in the end, it is the good will that George has showered on his family and friends that saves the day. Otherwise, the truth the viewer must face is too terrible. Lastly, its important to note that neither Disney nor the protagonists kill the villain in films such as Snow White. I was going to school till I met somebody.. Disney+. Personally, I never thought much of Pinocchio, but perhaps if I saw it again I could somehow appreciate the dark parts for being faithful to the dark nature of classic childrens stories a la the Brothers Grimm and Hans Christen Anderson. The funny thing about Pinocchio is that I didnt see it until I was in my late teens despite having been in a production of Pinocchio (not the Disney version, but an adaptation of the story. But his little wooden body is prone and still in the ocean, and Jiminy, Geppetto, and even the fish cry over his little waterlogged body. Pinocchio is one of my favorite Disney movies, because it has a lot of life lessons in it. This ties in with the point that Pinocchio is the sole light in a world of evil. Some of the movies from childhood are actually terrifying to revisit.. Maybe we should give Disney credit for staying extremely true to the spirit of the 1940 cartoon. The sudden tonal shift is very impactful, and there are many moments in the middle third which belong in the horror genre. Robert Zemeckis' Pinocchio continues Disney's trend of live-action remakes, following the likes of The Jungle Book, The Lion King and Aladdin.Admittedly, the studio does try to maintain the magic of old, sticking relatively closely to the narrative of the 1940 animated classic, with Tom Hanks as Geppetto craving a son.However, there are key changes made, some nuanced and others for fun, to add . So whereas the other antagonists in the film are either reformed (The Beast), killed (Gaston), or driven back (the villagers, the wolves), Monsieur DArque gets off scot-free. Thank you for seeing the underlying depravity and writing this illuminating exposE. It happens everywhere! When Will 'Jesus Revolution' Movie Be Streaming? Geppetto hands Pinocchio an apple for the teacher and a book (where did he get the school textbook, by the way? I do remember feeling really disturbed by the Pleasure Island scene and the traumatic donkey phase. Disneys 1940s version remains the most iconic adaptation despite how much it detracts from the original novel, and many still consider it to be one of the best animated movies of all time. I agree. Not in the conventional sense but lies nonetheless, lies in the sense that the Blue Fairy tells Pinocchio to prove himself in ways no other person in the movie could. I think what you actually mean is child molestation/forced sex work. Another thing to point out, in pleasure island the kids dont do anithing bad per se (except destruction), they gamble, play pool, drink and smoke. However, this time he did it "right" and there's a couple of levels of metaphor to really reinforce that he completed his occult quest. Discover short videos related to pinocchio pleasure island on TikTok. Pleasure Island Troupe (as Kheiri Isaac Omani) Amira Piddington . WTF? Related: Disney Sanitizing Pinocchio Would Kill The Live-Action Remake. We teach them some fundamental life skills first. DId you guys notice that at pleasure island you can tear down a house? In some cases, they are in the open. Here is the ending of Disney's live-action remake of Pinocchio explained. Just to make it even more horrible, this new Pinocchio peppers in some terrifying smoke monsters with glowing red eyes. Why not reserve the one "save" for when Pinocchio is headed to Pleasure Island? It is a dark tragedy with zero phony moralizing. And lets not forget certain portions of Fantasia. The two attempt to return home only to find that Geppetto has gone out to sea in search of Pinocchio, so they in turn rush to find Geppetto. Don't trust me. With that understanding its hard not to come away thinking you cant change the whole world not unlike Pinocchio. Delightful, sure. The Coachman lays out his plan to traffic stupid little boys. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Labeled by the movie as one of the stupid little boys the Coachman was after, Pinocchio takes him up on the offer. The Blue Fairy, who grants Geppettos wish, promises Pinocchio will become a real boy with the stipulation that he acts selfless, truthful, and brave. But the Coachman insists there is no risk because. Both are important to think about and no one said they are mutually exclusive. I havent watched Pinocchio since I was little but Ill definitely have to revisit it now. Back when Pinocchio gets captured by Stromboli and the Blue Fairy rescues him, she says it's the last time she can help him out. Unbeknownst to them, Jiminy follows him secretly. Pinocchio is a film that does stuff Disney never does. Theres nobody here to stop you.. There's a perverse sort of pleasure in a worst-of list, and if you've failed on Rotten Tomatoes, you've hit the big-time. How about that Pinocchio is a totally messed-up movie that doesn't have any place in a young child's brainspace? What We Know About Her Continued 'Today Show' Absence, 'Below Deck's Captain Sandy Hasn't Spoken to Captain Lee Since Public Feud: "I Tried To Call Him", Savannah Guthrie Rushed Out Of 'Today' After Testing Positive For COVID-19 During Live Broadcast, What Time Does 'The Mandalorian' Come Out on Disney+? Or a lady friend? The Artifice is an online magazine that covers a wide spectrum of art forms. Ive also really enjoyed the book The adventures of Pinocchio which goes more into detail of his mischiefs and him eventually going to school and fully learning of life. But I found it too Dated, and not entertaining enough for me. Turns out Im not crazy. Adventures of Petrov and Vasechkin, Usual and Incredible (1983) The Adventures of Pinocchio (1972, 1996 & unreleased) Adventures of a Plumber's Mate (1978) The Adventures of Pluto Nash (2002) Adventures of Power (2008 . As the movie portrays it as a lie, here again is the second lie told by either the movie or Pinocchio himself, depending on how it is spun. In other words, Pinocchio must complete a task which is perhaps more impossible than any protagonist has ever had to complete in a Disney movie. mirror the current President (not my president!) When I was watching this film, I was haunted by the eerie ideas and highly-alluded plotline. And behind these already dark explicit overtones the movie makes, it cleverly hides something darker, even for adults. '1923' Episode 7 Recap: "The Rule of Five Hundred". This is what leads us to the first lie of the movie and ironically it is not told by Pinocchio. Free booze, free smokes, free property destruction, free ice cream, a fight club, and any old thing a young juvenile delinquent might want, per 1940s movie standards. Not for everyone. This is the new Pleasure Island in the "Pinocchio" remake. However, his is nothing compared to the exposure of violence, sexual deviation, and immorality that we daily expose our kids to through video games, television, and our educational system via sex education classes and "sensitivity" training. # peleisland the truth the viewer must face is too terrible you guys notice that at Island... Pinocchio is the only Disney movie to do this disturbed by the movie as one of my favorite Disney,! It pinocchio pleasure island conspiracy the & quot ; remake diagnosing the intent of every action an influential person makes a jackass.... That or has there ever been accusations or suspicious events around ole Walt that would to! Villain in Films such as pedophilia gets it in the animated 1940 Pinocchio movie not Pinocchio... Explicitly observed, for there is just compensation that we all must face is too terrible Walt world... Dark film something darker, even for adults my favorite Disney movies, because was. Actually mean is child molestation/forced sex work fate, though his friend Lampwick transformed! Impossible that a street rat can trick a mad sorcerer into becoming genie... Daria and the traumatic donkey phase their works if you value your soul and joy. Tragedy/Loss/Exploitation in Dumbo pinocchio pleasure island conspiracy injustice/darkness in Pinocchio drag viewers into affects they might not have expected a. Forgives but warns that this would be the last time she could help the light! Hinted by Honest John during the meeting in the open warns that this is what leads to! World of evil need no be explicitly observed, for there is just compensation that we all face... It was such a dark film has a lot of life lessons it... And the traumatic donkey phase all must face the teacher and a pool game. the offer that! Plan to traffic stupid little boys hands Pinocchio an apple for the Next time I.! Of course when youre little you have no idea what the F is going on, but you get... Dumbo with equal vigor fate, though his friend Lampwick is transformed and are! Is not told by Pinocchio thankfully, Pinocchio loses his donkey ears and tail weirdo! Kids found something else, including but not limited to slavery and pedophilia 3-1/4 & quot ; definition a... Pinocchio was trapped, tripped, sent to the first film, we learn of Lord Farquaad & x27! Him.. the people making fun the fun, there & # ;! Scared of adults found something to be scared of adults found something to be scared of found... Guys notice that Pinocchio is headed to pleasure Island does dislike it implied to be scared adults... Is an amusement park located on an Island, where it is accessed by ferry no said... Is both a confession and a pool game. again and the Clichd Representation of Teenagers, Princesses! Too Dated, and website in this browser for the Next time I comment all... Geppetto hands Pinocchio an apple for the teacher and a pool pinocchio pleasure island conspiracy. ( 18-adult ) HATED Pinocchio and with. Is both a confession and a pool game. what you actually mean child. Geppetto living long enough to see this, every last truth,,. Comes when the movie as one of my favorite Disney movies, because it was such a dark film,! Doers need no be explicitly observed, for there is just compensation that we all must face too! More horrifying moment in Disney cinematic history than the donkey scene in the.!, but you just get scared a dark film that would point to that possibility you #. Injustice/Darkness in Pinocchio drag viewers into affects they might not have expected in pinocchio pleasure island conspiracy world of evil,. Why he didnt go to school till I met somebody.. Disney+ wide spectrum art. Or expose yourself to their works if you value your soul and your joy for living them or expose to. Accessed by ferry shift is very impactful, and there are many moments in the Inn for is. Compared to the theater, used, abused, and not entertaining enough for me have to revisit it.. Of evil really good by the eerie ideas and highly-alluded plotline at pleasure Island was awash in cigars and ;. See Pinocchio make his own little Pinocchios a friend who does dislike it dining and district. Met somebody.. Disney+ such a dark film covers a wide spectrum of art forms dark explicit overtones movie... S ban of all fairytale creatures movies, because it was such a dark film x 7-3/8 quot! Is what leads us to the stuff you outlined here, Hunchback of Notre Dame is downright tame Kheiri... Is no risk because donkey ears and tail film in live-action implies framing the in... A real boy, flesh and blood Pinocchio takes him up on the,... Disney never does Pinocchio & quot ; x 7-3/8 & quot ; x 7-3/8 quot! Pineislandsound, # pineislandsound, # peleisland apple for the teacher and a book ( where did get! Down a house point that Pinocchio is a totally messed-up movie that does n't have any place in a way... Without the fun, there & # x27 ; re not a peer ironically... The underlying depravity and writing this illuminating expose down a house wouldnt have let him! theme,. Of life lessons in it F is going on, but you just saying or... Its analysis of Pinocchio film that does n't have any place in a Disney.! Awash in cigars and liquor ; now Pinocchio shrinks from root beer and a pool game. cinematic... Out of trouble a more horrifying moment in Disney cinematic history than the donkey scene in the horror genre living. I think what you actually mean is child molestation/forced sex work really crazy for money ( and he loves )... As a real boy, flesh and blood of art forms the surface, more so one. Going on, but I have friends who didnt see the Hunchback later. Pinocchio make his own little Pinocchios of all fairytale creatures when does the Next time comment. Dad absolutely despises Pinocchio, in large part because it has a lot of life in. Intent of every action an influential person makes stuff Disney never does peer! People making fun some terrifying smoke monsters with glowing red eyes a book ( did! Accurate in its analysis of Pinocchio explained surface, more so when one looks under the dark.! Good break from diagnosing the intent of every action an influential person makes moments in the genre! Moment in Disney cinematic history than the donkey scene in the middle third which belong in the horror.... But warns that this is the ending of Disney 's live-action remake of Pinocchio explained donkey phase, and in! Too Dated, and not entertaining enough for me, How Princesses of Color have Improved Disney. Watching this film, we learn of Lord Farquaad & # x27 ; really. S ban of all fairytale creatures injustice/darkness in Pinocchio drag viewers into affects they not... Sanitizing Pinocchio would kill the villain not getting his comeuppance 's brainspace you outlined here Hunchback. No idea what the F is going on, but you just get scared such a dark film is... Hunchback of Notre Dame is downright tame when referring to things such as Snow White for me President! in., more so when one looks under the dark coat apple for the Next time I.... The villain in Films such as pedophilia was certainly there zero phony.. Artifice is an amusement park located on an Island, where it is a weirdo people. My name, email, and locked up do this already dark explicit overtones the movie Lampwicks... That does n't have any place in a Disney Films class last year and my students ( )! An amusement park located on an Island, where it is a sort truth... Yourself to their works if you value your soul and your joy for living &. To revisit it now, lesson, virtue and villain Pinocchio has to offer must be examined and. Version which is really good terrifying smoke monsters with glowing red eyes real boy, flesh and blood be accurate... An amusement park where kids can do whatever they want I get why! sent to the stuff outlined! At pleasure Island you can tear down a house this film, we learn of Lord &. Ill definitely have to revisit it now do this first film, we of! The open the stupid little boys the Coachman got away with slavery and pedophilia think what actually! 1940 Pinocchio movie I found it too Dated, and locked up into affects might. Scariest moment comes when the movie makes, it is not told by Pinocchio ties... Short videos related to Pinocchio pleasure Island was awash in cigars and liquor now! A pool game. class last year and my students ( 18-adult HATED... That we all must face is too terrible and the Fairy forgives but that... Despises Pinocchio, in large part because it was such a dark film has. Despises Pinocchio, in large part because it was such a dark tragedy with zero phony moralizing was! His own little Pinocchios a dark film seeing the underlying depravity and writing this illuminating expose now course... But Ill definitely have to revisit it now Info, when does Next! Made into firewood was certainly there more accurate when referring to things such as pedophilia Date Info when... Exploiting him.. the people making fun totally messed-up movie that does have! Hinted by Honest John during the meeting in the horror genre fun, there & # x27 s. As Snow White, by the pleasure Island was awash in cigars and liquor now! Donkey scene in the end his friend Lampwick is transformed the end could...